|
DVD Title |
Super Atragon |
International Title |
Super
Atragon |
DVD Length |
Original Length |
98 Minutes |
52/46 Minutes |
Company |
Year of Manufacture |
ADV Films |
2002 |
Language |
Subtitles |
Japanese, English |
English |
Region |
Number of Discs |
1 |
1 |
Aspect Ratio |
Sound |
1.33:1 |
2.0 Stereo |
Extras |
. |
Menus (English) |
. |
Chapters (16) |
. |
Trailers: Nadia: Secret of Blue Movie (ADV),
Excel Saga (ADV), Sakura Wars 2
(ADV), The Devil Lady (ADV),
City Hunter: Motion Picture (ADV),
Steel Angel Kurumi (ADV) |
|
|
Captures |
|
Review |
ADV is at it again. The company has garnished
a reputation for heavily compressing their titles,
and Super Atragon doesn't disappoint
in keeping up this disappointing trend. However,
this movie is a little unorthodox and deserves
a little background to help avoid confusion. First
off, Super Atragon was not released theatrically
in Japan, but instead went direct to video, a
common practice with Anime referred to as OAV
(Original Animated Video) in Japan. To maximize
profits, the movie was broken into two parts,
with the first running for 52 minutes and the
second running for 46 minutes. For this release,
the entire movie is present, although still in
the two episode format.
Regardless of the title's history, though, this
disc fails to entice, with lackluster video that
a good audio presentation can't rise above, while
the extra selection is near nonexistent.
|
Video: |
|
Those familiar with ADV's releases shouldn't
be surprised to hear that this disc has been noticeably
compressed to the point where the video suffers
for it. All in all, there are obvious signs of
artifacting, made painfully obvious during the
main title screen where the red looks incredibly
smeared. It would also appear that edge enhancement
was used on this disc as there are small hints
of halos (a white outline on details), yet the
print looks blurred regardless. As for noise, due to the high level of artifacting
it's hard to distinguish what might be grain and
what might be pixilation here. Furthermore, the
first part of the movie is plagued by near constant
shimmering, a rainbow band of colors on fine details.
This inconsistency is not common on the latter
half of the movie, though, which would indicate
that the first "episode" was much more
compressed in contrast to the second.
Thankfully, the video fares much better in the
other areas. For example, the colors, while not
vibrant, are distinct as the brightness level
is also set appropriately. However, the condition
of the print used for the transfer is a little
harder to gauge. There are very few scratches
through out.
Super Atragon is presented in its original
aspect ratio of 1.33:1, or full screen.
|
Audio: |
|
The audio is the disc's only real moment to
shine, as ADV has attached two tracks here which
are presented rather well. The first track is
a 2.0 stereo presentation of the film's Japanese
audio, with the second track is a 2.0 stereo presentation
of the movie dubbed into English. Ignoring the
quality of the dubbing, the tracks here are faithful
to the source and don't sport any distortion.
Although the speaker distinction, especially on
the Japanese track, is a little weak, with Masamichi
Amano's wonderful score sounding slightly flat
while the sound effects don't have the full range
that could have been possible.
In 2004, ADV later re-released this title, "re-mastered",
in 5.1 surround as part of the "Essential
Anime" collection. This second DVD retails
for about $5 less then this one, with the only
toutable difference being the enhanced audio.
Not owning the second release, I can't comment
on it directly, but it does leave consumers who
already picked up the stereo release feeling slightly
burned.
The audio here is accompanied by, removable,
English subtitles.
|
Extras: |
|
Nothing much here as the company has only
attached their trademark selection of trailers.
Unfortunately, these aren't the original Japanese
ones, but rather adverts that ADV has created
to promote other discs in their library. What
makes this disheartening, though, is that most
of these previews look good without signs of heavy
compression or other aspects which plague the
movie on this release. Clearly someone needs to
straighten out ADV's priorities...
|
Overview: |
|
Bottom line, if one is looking to view Super
Atragon, then this is a serviceable release.
The quality here would be more appropriate at
a budget retail price, but no such luck. As previously
mentioned, ADV released a later edition of the
movie in 2004 with the addition of 5.1 surround
audio. Chances are that 2004 edition is far superior
to this one, beyond the much less attractive cover,
so it would be advisable to pick up that release
as opposed to this one.
|
- Anthony Romero |
Buy
this DVD |
|