|
DVD Title |
Ran - The Masterworks Edition |
International Title |
Ran |
DVD Length |
Original Length |
160 Minutes |
160 Minutes |
Company |
Year of Manufacture |
Wellspring |
2003 |
Language |
Subtitles |
Japanese |
English |
Region |
Number of Discs |
1 |
1 |
Aspect Ratio |
Sound |
1.85:1 (Anamorphic, Altered) |
2.0 Mono, 5.1 Surround |
Extras |
. |
Menus (English) |
. |
Chapters (40) |
. |
Trailers: Ran
(European, US Home Video) |
. |
Akira
Kurosawa Filmography |
. |
Restoration Demo (4 minutes) |
. |
Production Notes |
. |
Additional Ran
Information (Easter Eggs, 9 in total) |
. |
Audio Commentary with Stephen Prince (English) |
. |
Audio Commentary with Peter Grilli (English) |
|
|
Captures |
|
Review |
The second region 1 release of Akira
Kurosawa's Ran by Wellspring, who changed
their name from Fox Lorber by the time this DVD
was released. This disc was originally packaged
in an Amazon exclusive gift set released in 2002,
but was sold separately the following year. This
DVD was sold as more of a "special
edition" release of the film, but the video
and audio presentation leave some to be desired
while the extras won't do much to withhold one's
interest. |
Video: |
|
The video presentation found on Ran - The
Masterworks is a mixed bag. The biggest problem,
although it won't be noticeable to those unfamiliar
with the film, is that the aspect ratio isn't
what it's being reported as and some of the image
is cropped. This becomes painfully noticeable
with a side-by-side comparison, taking a look
at one
scene on this release versus that same
scene on Criterion's two disc set. On the
plus side, at least its Anamorphic for widescreen
TVs.
In terms of the print used for the transfer,
it looks to be fairly devoid of blemishes with
only moderate scratches present. However, the film looks blurred and lacks
a sharp detail to it. The frame, most notably
during the introduction, isn't always stable and
sometimes jumps up and down. The DVD also sports
some digital inconsistencies, most notably in
the form of shimmering on finer details, such
as Hidetora's emblem.
|
Audio: |
|
Audio presentation in Ran - The Masterworks
is notably better than the video quality, but
still contains its own problems. The 2.0 mono
track is more or less flawless, as hisses and
pops are never heard. However, the remastered
"surround" presentation of the film
unnecessarily tampers with the audio track, as
the levels present sound like they were "balanced",
which causes some of the dialogue to lose the
power presented by the actors. All in all its
an odd presentation, and why a 2.0 stereo track,
the film's original presentation, wasn't included
is questionable.
The audio tracks are complemented with removable
English subtitles, but they present a problem
of their own. To put it bluntly, it would appear
that very little care was placed into them as
they contain numerous typos or are not present
at all when some dialogue is being spoken.
|
Extras: |
|
The extras found on this disc, while many,
aren't very interesting. The Filmography, Production
Notes and Weblinks (which will likely date the
DVD when some of the more obscure fan ones go
off-line) are pretty standard fare that seem more
appropriate for an actual website than a DVD.
The trailers here are intriguing with both a European
version and a US home video one that uses stock
music, but it fails to include any of the Japanese
trailers. The DVD does contain a four minute video
on the restoration of the film, complete with
a small
blurb before the feature starts. Unfortunately,
this video is handled very poorly with a huge
amount of compression to the point where both
the "before" and "after" shots
look very lackluster. In this feature's defense,
though, it does do a nice job of showcasing exactly
how horrible their previous DVD effort was. The
most interesting special feature on the DVD would
have to be the two commentary tracks, one provided
by Stephen Prince, whose work can be found on
Red
Beard among others, and one by Peter Grilli,
the director of a Kurosawa documentary. Unfortunately,
even the commentaries leave some to be desired.
Prince, who is usually a fountain of information,
appears unprepared here and resorts often to pointing
out the obvious or on occasion giving out wrong
information, like stating the 1957 film Throne
of Blood was from 1967. Grilli is even
worse, as he rarely talks during his commentary
track or drifts off into speeches about his own
experiences. In general, a single commentary track
done by both Grilli and Prince probably would
have been better than what was presented here,
especially considering that Grilli's commentary
is never directed at any particular scene and
his parts could have been stuck anywhere.
Something which should be noted, as it's so rare
to find on a Toho DVD, are the Easter Eggs that
contain general information on the film. There
are nine in total and, like most Easter Eggs,
the greatest joy one can derive from them is finding
them as opposed to actually looking over this
content.
|
Overview: |
|
Bottom line, it would be unfair to call this
a horrible DVD as it's more than watchable, but
it's disheartening to see what might have been
a good DVD ruined by Wellspring's own laziness.
Thankfully, Criterion has stepped up to the plate
to release a two disc set for the film, which
makes this DVD obsolete even as a budget title.
This disc is also featured in the DVD box set:
Kurosawa
DVD Collection. |
- Anthony Romero |
Buy
this DVD |
|