Image Entertainment's first, and only, Toho
release. Unfortunately, this very early disc is
hardly anything more but a relic of the early
troubles some companies were having with the DVD
format. To put it simply, the video presentation
here is marred heavily by the largest amount of
digital inconsistencies seen thus far on a legitimate
region 1 Toho DVD, while the audio is nothing
special and the extras are nonexistent.
|
Video: |
|
Honestly, it's so hard to enjoy the movie
on this disc. To Image Entertainment's credit
the movie is uncut (so all three hours are present)
and Chushingura's original aspect ratio
of 2.35:1, or Toho Scope, is maintained... but
that's where the positive aspects end. Everything
else is either mediocre at best or poor. The mediocre
aspects include the mostly subdued colors, noise levels and
the shape of the print, which has scratches. The poor aspect
is the huge amount of digital inconsistencies,
which, overall, is the worst I have seen for any
Toho disc. In fact, if someone isn't clear on
what shimmering is then this disc is an excellent
reference point, a clear as day example can be
seen here.
All in all, Image Entertainment simply compressed
the movie far too much, as artifacting also runs
rampant while the entire movie looks very blurred
without any natural sharpness to it.
|
Audio: |
|
The lone audio track here gets the job done,
and nothing more. The track included is a 1.0
mono presentation in Japanese, which is audible
in spite of some minor hisses and crackles that
can be heard. English subtitles have been included,
but they have been burned onto the print so they
can't be removed. It would have also been nice
had the subtitles translated all of the Japanese
text in the movie, but no such luck, although
at least the intro and outro text segments have
been subtitled.
|
Extras: |
|
What extras? Nearly as barebones as they come,
while the only menu on the disc is the chapter
selection. |
Overview: |
|
Bottom line, Image Entertainment's Chushingura
is a pretty poor disc all around. Unfortunately,
it's the only release of the film on DVD in the
states as well, so those interested in the movie
will likely have to bite the bullet with this
disc. It would be nice, though, if Image would
lower the price a little, as they are still charging
an unreasonable $30 for the DVD.
On a side note, Chushingura was originally
released in 1998 by Image Entertainment in a cardboard
snap case. The disc was later re-released in 2001
in a regular Amaray case. Due to rarity, the cardboard
snap version tends to go for as high as $100,
although no actual difference exists between the
two discs themselves. For reference, the 1998
release was reviewed here. |
- Anthony Romero |