FMs: Limit the number of combatants

[wataru]

Vote.

Yes - A controlled number of combatants.
No - Free for all lame, boring, uninteresting nonsense

I say the max. should be 4. Exemptions would be Legion Swarm or Megagurius Swam but honestly, anything more then 4 is just stupid..

NO MIDDLE GROUND!!!

[alienhulk2099]

I voted no, because 4 isn't enough sometimes. Some people want to use 3 on 3s, 4 on 4s, 5 on 5s, or even pit armies against each other. Besides, Arbok specifically got rid of this rule so it's not coming back.

[Draglord]

I voted yes because I do believe that there should be a limit to how many fighters there are but I think that 4 is too small to be the maximum. I think either 6 or 8 would be good for normal matches while having something like 10 or 12 be fine for tournaments. That way there could be a decent amount of fighters but there won't be too many. Plus, we also have to consider the fact that there will mostly likely be tournaments in the future and I doubt everybody would want to do 2 on 2s or 1 on 1s all the time.

[TokyoVigilante]

More then four dissolves into incoherency. You create variable-upon-variable-upon-variable to the point where discussion is effectively impossible or just silly.

[zilla103192]

I voted no, because 4 isn't enough sometimes. Some people want to use 3 on 3s, 4 on 4s, 5 on 5s, or even pit armies against each other. Besides, Arbok specifically got rid of this rule so it's not coming back.

i love how everytime someone makes a poll about the FMs. AH is against it from the start... he just wants them to be his way.

[Inferno Rodan]

I agree that there should be a cap, but I'd set it at 5 or 6. Any more than that and the match just becomes way too chaotic to call.

[Arrow]

From the Fantasy Match topic:

As of December 8, 2010, it has been decided by the Moderators of Toho Kingdom to temporarily limit the number of combatants allowed in Fantasy Matches.

For Free-For-All matches the maximum number of combatants allowed is 5.
For Team matches the maximum number of combatants will be 4 vs. 4.

[GojiFan]

From the Fantasy Match topic:

As of December 8, 2010, it has been decided by the Moderators of Toho Kingdom to temporarily limit the number of combatants allowed in Fantasy Matches.

For Free-For-All matches the maximum number of combatants allowed is 5.
For Team matches the maximum number of combatants will be 4 vs. 4.

Thank You.

[Stuckey]

Once I get home from work I will tweak the rules for team battles just a bit to clear up any confusion the rule may cause.

[Hellspawn28]

5 or 6 is good enough.

[Godzilla 2000]

Why couldnt we get a decision this quickly when the FM VG thing started? =P

[KaneLocke]

I agree that there should be a cap, but I'd set it at 5 or 6. Any more than that and the match just becomes way too chaotic to call.

I'd have to agree to this. Four is a bit short. I've seen a few larger matches than that not disintegrate.

But there does need to be a cap, like TV says. Too many and it's just too many variables.

[Stuckey]

For all of those that have missed it, once again, here are the new rules. viewtopic.php?f=17&t=3112
Any questions and feel free to PM myself or one of the other Mods.

[wataru]

For my next thread...

TK Endorsed Stat Sources....Monster Archives, Wiki, the main site, and what else?

[KaneLocke]

No. Wiki is useless.

So I'm against the idea of using only TK endorsed stats.

[wataru]

No. Wiki is useless.

So I'm against the idea of using only TK endorsed stats.

no no no, that was just a list.

Like what sites should stats be allowed from?
TK Main Site?
Monster Archives?
Wiki sources? (isnt there a Godzilla Wiki?)

If you cant find sites - should YouTube videos be allowed to demonstrate?

[Hedorah]

Sooo we wanna bring back one of the dumbest rules?

[wataru]

If you were the #2 voter for NOT limited the number, youre too late. It's been done already.

[Hedorah]

If you were the #2 voter for NOT limited the number, youre too late. It's been done already.

I could care less, but seriously why limit? It's all in good fun

[wataru]

Did you read the DAM vs GFW thread? It's like 20 combatants. It's pure anarchy.