by Toxic Toast » Sat Dec 04, 2010 12:16 pm
Well, I went back and played Haunted Castle again. There are a few different revisions of the PCB; I'd played version M years ago, which has the difficulty turned up to 11, but the others are more manageable. I was able to clear it after a few nights' efforts. I guess you played one of the other revisions as well (and if you were playing version M, damn). It was fun, and I'm glad I gave this game another shot.
However, even the easier versions of Haunted Castle have much tougher fighting and platforming than Simon's Quest. On top of that, you have four lives at most to complete the entire game, while Simon's Quest gives you unlimited continues, right from where you died.
Simon's Quest is hard, though, in figuring out what the hell you're supposed to do at any given point in time. Use holy water to break down the back wall of a random room? Kneel in an arbitrary spot with a certain item equipped? If that's what you meant by Simon's Quest being hard, I would agree, but it's action component is possibly the easiest of the series.
With Haunted Castle out of the way, I'd say the toughest action in classic-vania is either the second loop of the U.S. version of Dracula's Curse, or the higher loops & harder difficulties of Castlevania Chronicles / X68.