Scar vs Share Khan

[Kiryu2012]

Scar
http://disneyvillains.wikia.com/wiki/Scar

vs

Shere Khan
http://disneyvillains.wikia.com/wiki/Shere_Khan

Arena: The area where Share Khan attacked Mowgli and Baloo(no fire obviously).

Rules are simple.
No outside interference and no mercy.

Verdict: I'm undecided here. Both are pretty much equals in just about everything. Scar could easily bring Simba down, and Shere Khan could survive falling off a cliff, landing on a ledge that was right above lava without any visible damage. Without anything to serve for an advantage over someone, this fight could go on all day.

Meh, 5/10 for both of them.

What are your thoughts?

[RedZillaKing]

Khan all the way. Scar was unable to defeat Simba. Khan is larger and naturally healthier/stronger. Scar relies on tricks and sympathy to gain the upper hand. Where Khan wont be easy to fool, and he will have no sympathy for the bony lion.

Khan 8/10.

[PopInPicsPresents]

A tiger could beat a normal lion fine. Scar is basically an older, weaker lion. Both are really smart but unless Scar can somehow get in KHANNNN!!'s head, he doesn't have a chance.

[GodzillaXGomoraFight]

Share Khan has this in the bag. Scar is very deceptive and smart, but Khan knows his surroundings, is intelligent as well, and is physically stronger than an average lion. Scar would have to trick him in some way to win, but his chances of winning are still small.

Khan: 8/10
Scar: 2/10

[Living Corpse]

For a second I though we were talking about Shao Kahn from MK. XD

[Kiryu2012]

^That fight would've been over before it began. At least here Scar has a chance.

[GreenScar]

Share Khan is gona have himself a new lion skin rug. Scar is a manipulator and not very big the brawn department. Scar would have to get lucky and bite Khan's jugular quick, and never let go. Khan is going to overwhelm Scar.

Share Khan 9/10
Scar 1/10

[XxComablack1937xX]

Scar would get his ass handed to him by Khan, He wouldn't fight Mufasa 1 on 1 because he knew he'd lose... Unless scar got Khan in a position like he did Mufasa with an unsuspecting attack or had a pride behind him he'd have no chance.

[TechnoForce]

Yeah Shere Kahn I just got a much more intimidating vibe off him. More power as well.

[PRIMEVAL]

Shere Khan, definitely... If I were to post my reasoning, I'd be repeating what others have said.

[Showa Gyaos]

Scar is crafty, but Shere Khan is more aggressive and more powerful than Scar. Not to say that Shere Khan was unintelligent, but it's simple anatomy. Scar would be his chew toy.

[miguelnuva]

Scar could barely hold off Simba Shere Khan is going to do to him what those Hyenas did.