Nothing against seeing a males ass, I've taken a figure drawing class and drawn plenty of male asses based on nude models.Captain Aktion wrote:I've got a really good feeling I know why most people get...perturbed about that scene. But I'll refrain from saying.LSD Jellyfish wrote:The ass shot is pretty much the height of it, serving absolutely zero purpose.
Now, while I admit it's up for debate about how necessary the scene is, it does serve some narrative purpose. It clearly is set up to show that Yuki is a self-sufficient survivalist who's been "in the trees" for so long that he's either lost or just doesn't care about basic decorum, like covering his ass in front of people, and that these guys are totally contemptible to him. The immediate shot after or before, if I recall correctly, has the other two guys looking at him with a mix of frustration and bewilderment. It reinforces the differences between the three of them and it lays out that not only does Yuki not give a damn if "his ass is hanging out" but that he probably even gets a little kick out of provocation and sticking it to the "squares". The fact that the other two soldiers mean so little to him that basic things that we take for granted, like not sticking your ass out, are meaningless to him says something.
I get that an ass shot of a dude in the shower isn't necessarily something that belongs in a Godzilla film and I'd say that the naked breasts of a corpse aren't very couth either but I think the consternation over the butt-shot comes from somewhere other than quality or purpose. I mean, all the "yuck"s and "eww"s as form of critique say so.
Either way, that shot DID say more to me about the character than anything in Miki's entire plot said about her.
I like your interpretation but if that was the case I feel as though there's better ways of doing it. Early on in the film there is some very choppy editing and transitions from plot point to plot point. The ass thing just kinda sums it up.