TK's Official Whine Thread

[PopInPicsPresents]

matrix. Gonna take a wild guess and say he's underaged.

or an idiot...

[wataru]

My whine..

People who use the whine thread as a "report underaged user" thread instead of just PMing an admin or mod.

(not focused at your PnP, just generally)

[Legion1979]

I wanna box up MaxRebo, take him home and give him a ball of yarn. He's so cuuuute.

[Megalon-5]

I wanna box up MaxRebo, take him home and give him a ball of yarn. He's so cuuuute.

Don't ya just love them young fans and their big ideas about timelines?

[kaiju_wars]

Can someone post a link to this?

[Living Corpse]

Can someone post a link to this?

Sigh. It's not like it's hard to find. >_>

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=9466

[wataru]

Can someone post a link to this?

Sigh. It's not like it's hard to find. >_>

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=9466

I did this wit Excel last year... basically if you try to do something "fun", you're shit on. Why cant yall just either 1.) leave him alone; 2.) Offer perhaps some constructive criticism?

[Living Corpse]

????

I haven't even talked to this max dude.

[Jomei]

I have a whine. wataru reports me to admins for winning debates with him.

[wataru]

????

I haven't even talked to this max dude.

I wasnt including you. I was just quoting you because of the link.

[kaiju_wars]

Can someone post a link to this?

Sigh. It's not like it's hard to find. >_>

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=9466

I know, I found it along time ago...
My whine is on kaiju_wars, to damn lazy to say nevermind...

[Living Corpse]

Oh.

Sorry then.

[wataru]

Oh.

Sorry then.

No prob, brah.

[Hellspawn28]

I wanna box up MaxRebo, take him home and give him a ball of yarn. He's so cuuuute.

Not to mention he says that Godzilla is Minya in DAM because it's his own personal canon ! I really hate personal canons and I like to stick with facts. If you think it's true then that's fine and all but we should stick with what Toho goes by then fan fiction.

[Megalon-5]

I love how he says that he "gives up" after the Minya debacle and then he makes a timeline that makes no sense.

[Captain Aktion]

My WHINE is about...

Y'know what? Screw it. There IS NO Showa time-line that is set in concrete. This so-called "kid" may not have researched certain aspects far enough, but so what? I've made the same argument in the past; that perhaps there's more to how it's all laid out that what the "majority" deems fit.

Posit: Gigan is a cyborg. A creature made up of biological material that has had bionic enhancements grafted onto its frame. Perhaps the King Ghidorah (the sluggish, ratty looking, out of character Ghidorah) in G vs. Gigan was in fact a clone...Does G vs. Gigan take place before or after DAM? Any definitive answers? I don't mean to conjecture about how one kaiju was still alive at this point or, etc. I mean, if we go by what kaiju are alive or dead...Well, at least we'd be saying King Kong Escapes takes place after DAM, right? Baragon was dead at the end of F vs. the World, but he's alive in DAM? So that took place after...? When there's no mention of Monster Island? Where this unknown monster was locked up?

I could go on and on, but the entire idea of hating on the "kid" for trying to make sense of something that has no REAL quantification is a bit ludicrous, if not entirely, well, silly.

There's no APPROVED timeline, so get over acting like there is. What we have is what we have and it leaves plenty of doors open for speculation; there's no reason to diminish the verisimilitude of the Godzilla series by taking that kind of 4-Dimensional thinking or reasoning away from it. It exists as it is. To add more than is there is the same as taking it away, and as it stands, plenty of theories have high possibilities/probabilities.

When someone can show me the approved Toho timeline of events in the Showa era, then we can start hurling stones.

[RedZillaKing]

Godzilla versus Gigan takes place in the 70s. DAM was 1999. Chances are Ratdorah was the same one was gang raped in '99. Plus everything in DAM looked like... THE WORLD OF TOMORROOOOOOWWWWWWWW..

[miguelnuva]

My WHINE is about...

Y'know what? Screw it. There IS NO Showa time-line that is set in concrete. This so-called "kid" may not have researched certain aspects far enough, but so what? I've made the same argument in the past; that perhaps there's more to how it's all laid out that what the "majority" deems fit.

Posit: Gigan is a cyborg. A creature made up of biological material that has had bionic enhancements grafted onto its frame. Perhaps the King Ghidorah (the sluggish, ratty looking, out of character Ghidorah) in G vs. Gigan was in fact a clone...Does G vs. Gigan take place before or after DAM? Any definitive answers? I don't mean to conjecture about how one kaiju was still alive at this point or, etc. I mean, if we go by what kaiju are alive or dead...Well, at least we'd be saying King Kong Escapes takes place after DAM, right? Baragon was dead at the end of F vs. the World, but he's alive in DAM? So that took place after...? When there's no mention of Monster Island? Where this unknown monster was locked up?

I could go on and on, but the entire idea of hating on the "kid" for trying to make sense of something that has no REAL quantification is a bit ludicrous, if not entirely, well, silly.

There's no APPROVED timeline, so get over acting like there is. What we have is what we have and it leaves plenty of doors open for speculation; there's no reason to diminish the verisimilitude of the Godzilla series by taking that kind of 4-Dimensional thinking or reasoning away from it. It exists as it is. To add more than is there is the same as taking it away, and as it stands, plenty of theories have high possibilities/probabilities.

When someone can show me the approved Toho timeline of events in the Showa era, then we can start hurling stones.

There is a approved Showa timeline.

It's called all showa Godzilla movies take place the year they were made, some of the other toho movies are included and DAM is the end of the showa series.

[Goji]

My whine is that MaxReebo's avatar is too awesome for his own good.

[Captain Aktion]

There is a approved Showa timeline.

It's called all showa Godzilla movies take place the year they were made, some of the other toho movies are included and DAM is the end of the showa series.

So, Japan and America we're able to fly to the farthest reaches of our galaxy, not just the moon by '65? Maser tanks, M-Cycle Light rays, Jet Jaguar, and all the other "future" tech available are just common place by '65 in this timeline? So, it isn't our timeline anyways? So their '65 was far more advanced and developed than ours? Obviously events that have occured in our world never happened in theirs, otherwise many things such as the space-travel by '65 couldn't have happened. The timestamp MAY indicate '65 (which it never actually does) however it is clearly a more advanced, "futuristic" society. E.G., the future.

Maybe.

Oh well; my whine is that there's some real, real F'ed up stuff that goes down with people in this fandom when you *gasp* dare to have an opinion that's different.