Carnotaurus vs. Spinosaurus

[PopInPicsPresents]

http://disney.wikia.com/wiki/Carnotaurus
vs.
http://monsterarchives.proboards.com/in ... hread=2260

ARENA:
Isla Sorna Beach

RULES:
Caranotaurus is scaled up to 45 feet long and 20 feet tall

VERDICT:
I'm giving this to the Carno. In Dinosaur, they were portrayed as Tyrannosaurus sized titans. It's smart, tenacious and mean as all hell. Spino will have trouble snapping Carno's neck since it's decorated with dozens of spikes that go down his back. If the Carnosaur can get his jaws on Spino I see the match coming to an end.

[Gyaos]

Spinosaurus snaps his neck, with the Carno being unable to do anything to stop him. End.

[Destroyer]

Spinosaurus completely destroys all dinosaurs.

[Gyaos]

Except the Godzillasaurus. That thing is just ridiculous. Tanking a naval bombardment, anyone?

[Grayshot954]

I gotta go with carnotaurus. Scaled and with its bulk, I see Spino having a difficult time trying to snap its neck. Heck, Spino only versed a young T-Rex. An adult expierence Carnotaur is going to put up one heck of a fight.

Spinosaurus- 4/10
Carnotaurus-6/10

[PopInPicsPresents]

Except the Godzillasaurus. That thing is just ridiculous. Tanking a naval bombardment, anyone?

I was thinking the same thing right before you posted this

[SpanishBulldog63]

the only thing that i see Spino having a physical advantage with is reach,considering the Carno has stubs for arms vs Spino's much longer arms.one little x-factor im looking at is their film-respective foes:Carno faced only herbivores whereas Spino faced a juvenile rex;quality wise Spino had a bigger challenge in a rival predator, whereas Carno fought with smaller(film-wise)Iguanodons.however, the outcome kinda speaks for itself, since Spino killed the juvie Rex whereas Carno got pushed off a cliff by dinner.

taking the aforementioned info into consideration I say 50/50 because you have the tenacious Spino vs an also tenacious but experienced adult foe in the Carno

[RedZillaKing]

Herbivores can be every bit as dangerous as a T-rex. Especially ceratopsians. Like the Pachyrhinosaurus that the Carnotaurus tackles with no effort. And a fall from a cliff would kill anything. As would being crushed by tons of rocks.

[Berzerkgodzilla]

And a fall from a cliff would kill anything.

The Land Before time T-rex would beg to differ (So it wasn't a cliff, but it was pretty damn high)

This is a hard one for me, I actually could see 50/50

[RedZillaKing]

LOL, yeah, I forgot about him.

[Primevalgodzilla V2]

I will never understand for the life of me how a 37 foot T-rex is a youngster. Most speicmens are lucky to reach that size in adulthood. Perhaps not an exctraordinary, newspaper-making size, but an impressive Rex regardless. And he STILL has a much better bite than Carnotaurus. And Carnotaurus got his ass kicked by what was genuinely a juvenile Iguanodon. Spino's gonna curbstomp him.

[SpanishBulldog63]

[quote="RedZillaKing]Herbivores can be every bit as dangerous as a T-rex. Especially ceratopsians[/quote]

true,but an Iguanodon really doesnt have much going for it outside of the thumb spikes,which the most fatal wound infilcted imo would be a jab into the eye vs a Ceratopsian whose 1-3 horns can speak for the damage capable themselves

[RedZillaKing]

I will never understand for the life of me how a 37 foot T-rex is a youngster. Most speicmens are lucky to reach that size in adulthood. Perhaps not an exctraordinary, newspaper-making size, but an impressive Rex regardless. And he STILL has a much better bite than Carnotaurus. And Carnotaurus got his ass kicked by what was genuinely a juvenile Iguanodon. Spino's gonna curbstomp him.

Jurassic Park III's tyrannosaur was much smaller than his predacessors. And like it or not, his bite was pathetic. Real tyrannosaurs have been shown to be able to punch through solid Triceratops frills... lil' Rex failed to deliver a decent bite to an unarmored Spinosaurus. He was pathetic. just ike Dr. Horner wanted him to be.

As for the carnotaurus, he didn't get his "ass kicked". Aladar pushed him a few feet and smacked him with his tail. The Carnotaurus for his part knocked Aladar over with ease and didn't seem to be taking him seriously. Just moments earlier the Carnotaurus was in a "serious" battle with a much larger Iguanadon and picked him up with his mouth and threw him bodily through the air. You can see by the speed Kron was travelling and the severity of his impact with the boulder that the carno was incredibly powerful. If you'd like a clip, I'd be happy to post one. BTW, Aladar wouldn't have stood a snowballs chance if that cliff hadn't crumbled. Those super carnotaurus were killing machines.

Anyways, we have to remember that these are souped up exaggerated versions of their real life counterparts. That carno at 45 feet will be about 10 tons of monster vs. the 6-7 tons of the Spinosaurus. Unlike the JP III rex the Carno will make every bite count, and will most likely be able to throw the Spino with ease.

[kikomia]

The biggest meat eating dinosaur to appear in jurrasic park was the first T-rex. He got out of his enclosure after the power went down. Spinosaurus destroyed the whole fence. The Spinosaurus if the same size as the Carnotaurus he could run at the other dino and break his ribs. Therefore Spinosaurus would be the winner here.

[RedZillaKing]

Two completely different types of fences. The JP rex just had to tear through a few wires. The only problem here is that the Spino never displayed that type of strength again. In fact, he blatantly contradicted it moments later by being unable to bust through a door. In the rex fight, he was physically inferior, with the rex knocking him around with ease. That carno makes JP3 rex look like a wimp.

[kikomia]

Two completely different types of fences. The JP rex just had to tear through a few wires. The only problem here is that the Spino never displayed that type of strength again. In fact, he blatantly contradicted it moments later by being unable to bust through a door. In the rex fight, he was physically inferior, with the rex knocking him around with ease. That carno makes JP3 rex look like a wimp.

I have to agree with that. I don't get how he can break through a fence ALOT bigger than him, and then can't break a metal door that is supported by humans.

[Primevalgodzilla V2]

Jurassic Park III's tyrannosaur was much smaller than his predacessors. And like it or not, his bite was pathetic. Real tyrannosaurs have been shown to be able to punch through solid Triceratops frills... lil' Rex failed to deliver a decent bite to an unarmored Spinosaurus. He was pathetic. just ike Dr. Horner wanted him to be.

Or maybe Spino is just that incredily tough. He also charged right through a metal fence without injury and rammed into a moving plane with only minimal wounds.

As for the carnotaurus, he didn't get his "ass kicked". Aladar pushed him a few feet and smacked him with his tail. The Carnotaurus for his part knocked Aladar over with ease and didn't seem to be taking him seriously. Just moments earlier the Carnotaurus was in a "serious" battle with a much larger Iguanadon and picked him up with his mouth and threw him bodily through the air. You can see by the speed Kron was travelling and the severity of his impact with the boulder that the carno was incredibly powerful. If you'd like a clip, I'd be happy to post one. BTW, Aladar wouldn't have stood a snowballs chance if that cliff hadn't crumbled. Those super carnotaurus were killing machines.

Iguanodons are no big deal in comparison to a T-rex. The Caroaurus was like, 3 times Aladar's size? And I believe Aladar actally got some good hits on him.

Anyways, we have to remember that these are souped up exaggerated versions of their real life counterparts. That carno at 45 feet will be about 10 tons of monster vs. the 6-7 tons of the Spinosaurus. Unlike the JP III rex the Carno will make every bite count, and will most likely be able to throw the Spino with ease.

I don't recall him ripping massive chunks from Iguanodons, much less the JP3 monster in question. His bite will annoy Spino at best.

Two completely different types of fences. The JP rex just had to tear through a few wires. The only problem here is that the Spino never displayed that type of strength again. In fact, he blatantly contradicted it moments later by being unable to bust through a door

Considering we don't actually see him attack the door, we don't know why he could knock it over. Perhaps the door was too low for him to bash with enough force, like he did with the fence (charging right through it). Since the reason he didn't run through the door is ambiguous, we have to take the one we actually see happen as feats. And we do see him punch holes into planes by punching them with his snout. And he also broke a T-rex's neck in one bite.

In the rex fight, he was physically inferior, with the rex knocking him around with ease. That carno makes JP3 rex look like a wimp.

Throwing around Iguanodons isn't some incredible feat, it's just being a bully to weak dinosaurs. If he overpowered the Brachiosaur in the film, then yeah. he's a badass. But he didn't. Come to think of it, the whole climax could have been averted had the Brachiosaurus simply followed Aladar in the climax and stepped on the Carnotaur's head.

[RedZillaKing]

Or maybe Spino is just that incredily tough.

Meat is meat. If that bite was in the least bit strong that Spino would've been toast. As it was, the Rex's bite barely broke the skin

He also charged right through a metal fence without injury and rammed into a moving plane with only minimal wounds.

Fence was in disrepair... Plane knicked him with the propeller.

Iguanodons are no big deal in comparison to a T-rex. The Caroaurus was like, 3 times Aladar's size? And I believe Aladar actally got some good hits on him.

Iguanodons aren't rexes, that's for sure. However, the few seconds Aladar fought the Carno (before the beast was killed by its own weight) showed the Carno to be far superior. Obviously. Aladar merely used his superior stance, low center of gravity, and admittedly great strength to push the monster a few feet. As I'd said, the Carno wasn't taking him seriously. Moments before it had thrown a larger Iguanodon like 60 feet through the air.

I don't recall him ripping massive chunks from Iguanodons, much less the JP3 monster in question. His bite will annoy Spino at best.

Wait... you don't recall him ripping massive chunks out of other dinosaurs in A DISNEY MOVIE AIMED AT KIDS? Come to think of it, neither do I. At any rate, we're dangerously close to the realm of silly here. We're talking about a film where the carno bites Aladar as he's falling and there's no damage to his flesh. Those teeth are goddamned sharp. It makes no sense. Oh. wait... It's a Disney movie aimed at kids.

Considering we don't actually see him attack the door, we don't know why he could knock it over. Perhaps the door was too low for him to bash with enough force, like he did with the fence (charging right through it). Since the reason he didn't run through the door is ambiguous, we have to take the one we actually see happen as feats. And we do see him punch holes into planes by punching them with his snout. And he also broke a T-rex's neck in one bite.

He attacked the door and couldn't bust through. That fence had been maintained for many years. It was likely very weakened by the hurricanes and the elements in general. The plane was as durable as a tin can. It was obviously very damage by the crash. As for the tyrannosaur's neck, it was NOT the bite that broke it. At all. Rather it was a twisting motion aided by the neck and arms of the Spino. Again... good luck doing that to a carnotaurus who (unlike the rex, who was 5 tons TOPS) is significantly larger and stronger.

Throwing around Iguanodons isn't some incredible feat, it's just being a bully to weak dinosaurs. If he overpowered the Brachiosaur in the film, then yeah. he's a badass. But he didn't. Come to think of it, the whole climax could have been averted had the Brachiosaurus simply followed Aladar in the climax and stepped on the Carnotaur's head.

Throwing an animal even half your weight with neck strength alone is incredible. We never saw Spino do anything like that. Other than the questionable feat of bashing through the fence. Which hadn't been been maintained for 7 or 8 years.

[Inferno Rodan]

Meat is meat. If that bite was in the least bit strong that Spino would've been toast. As it was, the Rex's bite barely broke the skin

I suppose the Styracosaurus that Gwangi fought was just a weakling with a dull horn then? Because that's exactly the logic you're using.

The Carnotaurus is... difficult to judge. It's got impressive feats immediately followed by pathetic ones. One moment, it's hurling a creature half its size around like a rag doll. The next moment, it's getting shoved around by a creature half its size. It also got intimidated by a group of much smaller dinosaurus just roaring at it. How do you think it would react to a predator of equal size?

[RedZillaKing]

I suppose the Styracosaurus that Gwangi fought was just a weakling with a dull horn then? Because that's exactly the logic you're using.?

Nope. Gwangi is not comparable at all. These are supposed to be animals not monsters. That's why scientists were brought in as consultants. And meat is meat.

The Carnotaurus is... difficult to judge. It's got impressive feats immediately followed by pathetic ones. One moment, it's hurling a creature half its size around like a rag doll. The next moment, it's getting shoved around by a creature half its size. It also got intimidated by a group of much smaller dinosaurus just roaring at it. How do you think it would react to a predator of equal size?

It did not fight Aladar as hard as it fought Kron. It essentially swatted him like a fly with his tail. It was probably confused by his attacks at the least. And it was intimidated by a gigantic herd roaring together. Many of which were ceratopsians. Which proves that it wasn't stupid.