Terasawa wrote:It's nearly plotless and the even the special effects are mostly a letdown. It's easily the worst of Honda's tokusatsu films.
HedorahIsBestGirl wrote:I disagree. I think it's a better movie than BIOS, Gorath, Dogora, King Kong Escapes, Godzilla's Revenge and maybe Space Amoeba.
Terasawa wrote:Each of those is fundamentally stronger than Varan. For one thing, they all have a plot with characters that propel the narrative in some fashion. Varan is merely an excuse for various monster shenanigans. It's probably the worst screenplay Toho ever filmed.
I think BIOS might be the worst screenplay Toho ever filmed. The set-up for that movie is just awful; we don't even figure out who our protagonists are supposed to be until almost a third of the way in, and even then they're only important during the film's second act. The thinly-constructed plot all dissolves into an overly long battle sequence in the end. Aside from having more impressive effects work, I think BIOS is an all-around worse movie than Varan. Even Varan's protagonists have more of a role in the plot by initially discovering the creature and later joining in the effort to kill it.
Gorath is another contender for Toho's worst screenplay. We're thrown into the film's central problem immediately with no build-up whatsoever, and Jun Tazaki's character, seemingly the protagonist, is killed off five minutes in. Beyond this, the film is just a series of discussions about what to do about Gorath. A conclusion is reached pretty quickly and the plan to move the Earth is pulled off without much of a hitch (minus a short-lived and inconsequential appearance by a certain giant walrus). The characters really don't move the plot forward at all and the guy I think we're supposed to be rooting for is an immature douche.
Dogora is two different movies in one, and both are bad. We have a bland cops and robbers story and an even more bland kaiju story which don't mesh together effectively. Even the effects work in Dogora is some of the worst of Tsuburaya's career. The actual Dogora prop is well-made, but it only shows up once. The cartoon tentacles, glowing blue goo and floating spores all look exceedingly fake. Even the music is some of Ifukube's weakest.
King Kong Escapes is just... bad. Say what you will about Varan's bland protagonists, but I'll take them any day over Susan Watson. The only redeeming factors of this movie are Mechanikong and Hideyo Amamoto's scenery-chewing villainy.
I've already explained why I think Godzilla's Revenge is a terrible film, I don't want to get into that one again.
Space Amoeba is very comparable to Varan; both start off strong, with a monster terrorizing the natives of a remote location and the skeptical outsiders who show up unwelcomed. But both lose steam about halfway through and devolve into slightly tedious movies.
Now, do I think Varan is one of Honda's best films or one of the best kaiju films out there? Hell no. I just don't think it's one of the worst either. To me it's a middling film in the same vein as Godzilla Raids Again.